The J Crew metallic Thomson tote (99192), $198. The metallic colors are attractive. One drawback is that the tote is unlined. I am loving the Candace patent leather tote ($150, unavailable online) that I got from J Crew earlier in the season, so I didn't try this one on my shoulder.
The Michael Kors metallic tote, $198. I'm not sure if this is unlined. I passed by it in Macy's and it struck me as being more attractive than the J Crew tote. I think the handles are thinner and more subtle. The ones on the J Crew tote look clunkier. The MK tote also looks more structured, as though it will hold its shape better over time.
If you're interested in the J Crew tote, I suggest you check out the MK one as well. I saw it at Macy's. It's offered at Dillard's as well.